Secret Military Experiment Proves What Women Already Know

Published: Fri, 10/13/17


Author Mary Cronk Farrell 
                                                                                      October 13, 2017
Hello , 

My heart goes out to my brother-in-law's sister Debra who lost everything in the Santa Rosa, CA fire earlier this week. She had to run from her house at 4 am Monday with no time to grab anything she owned. Here's what's left now.
With 23 people dead and hundreds missing, there is plenty to mourn, but what makes this especially painful for Debra is that she lost her husband to cancer last year, and has now lost all trace of him except for her memories.
WWII Secret Experiment Proved Women Good Soldiers
In 1941, Englishwoman joined their male counterparts' anti-aircraft efforts by the tens of thousands to protect their homeland from the Luftwaffe.

American military strategists trained a keen eye on the women soldiers. 
Even Princess Elizabeth signed up. Picture Queen Elizabeth with a grease rag and wrench.
Courtesy Imperial War Museums
U.S. Army Chief of Staff George C. Marshall knew American women would be necessary to the war effort.

But could they possibly perform efficiently beside men in combat?
Marshall conducted a secret 
experiment to find out.

The women in Britain's Auxiliary
Territorial Service (ATS), shown at left, were not allowed to fire anti-aircraft artillery. There was one man on each crew to do that. But 335 ATS women were killed during the war.

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​In a hush-hush move, Marshall assigned 21 officers and 374 enrollees from the Women's Auxiliary Army Corp to train with male army crews on anti-aircraft gun batteries and nearby searchlight units stationed near Washington D.C.

Below: Women of the Antiaircraft Artillery, 89th Coast Artillery, on duty in the Military District of Washington, Eastern Defense Command, 1942.
WAAC unit working in Antiaircraft Artillery Command, Washington D.C. area, 1942.
Lieutenant Elna Hilliard, a WAAC officer assigned to antiaircraft duty told of an Army general coming to watch the women tracking and targeting a test plane. The spotter crew chief Lieutenant Dorothy Mitchell shouted when the plane came into range and again when the gunner should fire.

The general's aide pulled out a stopwatch to time the women. The general looked at the stopwatch and said, "Impossible."
"What's impossible, Sir? asked Elna.

He told her the test crew including the woman had met the top time of the best all-male crew on the entire East Coast. Apparently, the general couldn't believe it, and had them repeat the test twice more.

In the subsequent tests the male-female crew performed faster and more accurately than his best male crew.
Antiaircraft Artillery Command, later identified as the 89th Coast Artillery, AntiAircraft, Military District of Washington, Eastern Defense Command, 1942.]
At right, WAAC unit working in Antiaircraft Artillery Command, Washington D.C. area, 1942.

The women's immediate supervisor Colonel Edward W. Timberlake found the women learned their duties more quickly than men, concluding, "WAAC personnel were found to be superior in efficiency to men in all functions involving delicacy of manual dexterity."

Timberlake believed women could capably take over sixty percent of the anti-aircraft positions.

Marshall had worried about possible scandal with the men and women working together, but Timberlake reported no sexual harassment or misconduct, instead, "A mutual understanding and appreciation appears to exist."

Army brass believed the secret experiment "demonstrated conclusively the practicability of using members of the WAAC in this role," but believed the risk was too great. They believed WAAC recruitment would suffer if the American public knew that women served in combat.

General Marshall had plans to end the Women's Auxiliary Army Corp, and allow women to actually join the army. He feared conservative congressmen would block his plan.

Many like Congressman Andrew Somers of New York had already argued against women even taking non-combat roles in the military."Think of the humiliation. What has become of the manhood of America, that we have to call on our women to do what has ever been the duty of men? The thing is so revolting to me, to my sense of decency.” 

And so the anti-aircraft women were sent back to noncombat roles and the results of Marshall's experiment kept secret until many years after the war ended.

It would take another 70 years before American women would be officially assigned to military combat roles, but they have served with courage and distinction under fire in all U.S. wars. 
News and Links
Image

Thanks Meghan Nuttall Sayres for sighting Irena's Children in the wild and sending a photo. This is from The Kings English Bookstore in Salt Lake City, Utah.

Thanks to the Lee County, Kentucky Public Library for featuring my historical novel Fire in the Hole! 

Thanks to Abby McGanney Nolan for including Fannie Never Flinched and Pure Grit on her list of 30 Books That Show We’re In a Golden Age of American History for Kids on her blog Electric Lit.

​Until next week...

Have you read a great book? Tell me about it. Have a burning question? Let me know.

If you know someone who might enjoy my newsletter or books, please forward this e-mail. 

I will never spam you or sell your email address, you can unsubscribe below anytime with a single mouse click. 

To find out more about my books, how I help students, teacher and librarians, visit my website at www.MaryCronkFarrell.com. 

My best,

Mary


Questions? Comments? Contact me at MaryCronkFarrell@gmail.com. Click here to subscribe to this newsletter.